Sunday, November 30, 2008
"What is real?" asked the Rabbit one day. "Does it mean having things that buzz inside you and a stick-out handle?"
"Real isn't how you are made," said the Skin Horse. "It's a thing that happens to you. When a child loves you for along, long time, not just to play with but REALLY loves you, then you become Real. It doesn't happen all at once. You become. It takes a long time. Generally by the time you are Real, most of your hair has been loved off, and your eyes drop out and you get loose in the joints and very shabby. But these things don't matter at all, because once you are Real you can't be ugly, except to people who don't understand."
My review: I absolutely adore this book. I think I probably should have read it before now, but somehow it has never happened. So, when I found out my daughter would be going to see the play for preschool at at the beginning of this month, I thought it would be a good idea to read it together. It was a wonderful experience! MW's story, though small, is very descriptive and perfectly creates for you the world of this love-worn rabbit. It is suitably written to read aloud with lots of places for added emphasis and wide-eyed, dramatic pauses. When I would look at my daughter in mock wonder over things happening in the story she would look right back at me, her face a mirror image of my own. This book has forever changed how I look at our "Reals"--Pink and Lovey Bear. No matter how dirty and worn, now they are a little less germy in my eyes. I am so excited to go with her to see the play and we'll definitely read this one again!
My rating: 5 stars. I LOVE LOVE LOVED IT.
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: Drenched with nursery magic.
Summary: In a quiet fishing village seventeen years ago, one lone fisherman rescued a child from the sea. He and his wife raised the girl, Pearl, as their own daughter never allowing themselves to wonder long about where she came from--or notice her silver hair, unusually pale skin, and wide, dark blue eyes. Pearl grows from mysterious child into an unusual young woman, not always welcomed in the village. As all the other girls her age find husbands, she has only one friend to ease her loneliness. One very special, secret companion: Prince James. But their friendship is shaken when trouble erupts in the kingdom--a conspiracy agains the royal family combines with an evil enchantment from beneath the sea. Now just when Pearl and James need eachother the most, bewitching magic and hints about Pearl's past thereaten to tear them apart...forever.
My review: In all fairness I read half of this book before my family came up for Thanskgiving and the other half after they left a little under a week later. The gap kind of left me with a disjointed experience of the book. I enjoyed it, but don't feel super qualified in reviewing it. I'm still going to though. I just don't remember a great deal about the first half of the book. I've got to say that the title of this book throws me off entirely. Perhaps I just have a dirty mind, but to me it sounds, well, sexual...like the title belongs to something in the romance section and that the cover should be red or hot pink. It doesn't. I checked. I supposed if you really try hard enough you could do that to about any book title though. Moving on.
Pearl has been struggling her whole life to fit in, or rather, to not stick out quite so much. With her long legs, silvery hair, and complete lack of grace, she's different from those around her in ways that she cannot explain. Were it not for her closely guarded friendship with the prince and two loving parents, she would be entirely alone in the world. Unexpectedly, "Midnight Pearls" is the story of not one mermaid, but several. Debbie Viguie takes the story of the little mermaid and expands it to involve quite a few more merkin, an imprisoned Seawitch, an evil plot to assassinate the king, and more than one devastatingly attractive prince (yippee!). The plot twists and turns as the characters struggle to serve their own agendas and, of course, find their true loves. The end came much to quickly for me--the big fight really wasn't all that big and was resolved in the matter of a page. I did enjoy the additional characters and the expanded plot but feel that many of these books would be served by a little more character/plot development and about 30-50 more pages.
My rating: 3 stars. Get it at the library. PG
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: A nice beach read.
Monday, November 24, 2008
Okay, so I am a big fan of the independent bookstore and I would like to start promoting INDIE BESTSELLERS (formerly known as Book Sense 76 Picks) which are top reading picks by independent booksellers. Who knows better what books to pick up than those that eat, sleep, breathe, and shelve them daily?!?! However, I'm feeling a bit hypocritical because when I link books on this blog they are all linked to Amazon. I've done this mostly out of ease of use. It's a good place to find reader reviews and they usually have a picture and summary of the book. This might have the unfortunate side-effect of some of you actually ordering a book from them when you might just as easily (and with less shipping) go to a local bookstore. So, I'm searching for a good online bookstore to link our book recommendations/reviews to so that if you want to order it I won't feel so much like a dung beetle.
Leave a comment if you have any suggestions.
My review: Global -1, the new unoffical government is requiring that everyone be tattooed with a special barcode that identifies them. It allows people to buy things, drive, do everything--and NOTHING happens without it. However, Kayla does not want the bar code. It has caused too many problems in her family. Her friends parents lost their jobs because of it and she's discovered something horrible is buried within the code. So, when it becomes illegal to NOT sport one, Kayla runs away hoping to join the resistance. "Bar Code Tattoo" details Kayla's fight, flight, and journey to find the people who believe as she does--that being coded will end the world as they know it.
This book is marketed as a young adult novel. I think it qualifies as such, but it also raises a more adult issues about what we see going on today. Don't worry. I'm not a conspiracy theorist. I just pulled a whole bunch of their fears from this book. Some valid. Some less so.
-the increased globalization of markets and economies
-use of credit and debit cards to track online activities and even locations
-government involvement in every day life and in the economy
-the consequences for not conforming or resisting change
-being deemed "unpatriotic" or "unamerican" when you disagree with the government
-the experimentation with human and animal cloning and genetic enhancements
-the consequences of "food augmentation" and genetically messing with our food supply.
-the cost of sacrificing our civil liberties in the name of security.
-the power and ability of the media to distort the truth in order to sway public opinion
So after I get past all the immediately apparent thematic elements of the plot I can finally relax and enjoy the story. According to the summary, I am going to love this book because it sounds very much like others I have enjoyed. But I can't. In fact, other than remembering all of the above themes, I get so distracted by the end of the book that I have a hard time remembering what was good about it at the beginning.
Here are my three main complaints with this book:
1) The binding had the word "thriller" on it. So, silly me, I expected some. It was a too predictable for me. Things happened a little bit to easily and escapes were a bit too convenient.
2) I had a hard time visualizing how a bunch of kids, raised with all the luxurious benefits of a futuristic society and no apparent special training, manage to survive out in the middle of the woods. Where did they get their food? How did they find their way around? Perhaps there was a survival training course required to graduate...but I highly doubt it.
3) (SPOILER HERE) A genetic code is embedded in the tattoo that tells Global-1 who will be successful in life and who won't. Those that get the short end of the genetic stick get cut off from all resources--a type of enforced genetic exclusion. Near the end of the book, people miraculously start discovering and developing special abilities. Global-1's genetic practices, supposedly, gave those who were excluded immediate heightened abilities in order to survive. I feel that the reasons the author gave for the development of these ESP, healing, and telekinetic powers was weak and unsupported. I know. I know. It's a scifi/fantasy book...I shouldn't expect rational thought processes to apply--but I do. I'd have prefered a bit more believability. It was a risky plot move with too poor an explanation.
All in all I was disappointed. It started out really well and I was interested for quite a while. It had the flavor of so many books that I had savored in the past-- "1984" by George Orwell, "The Giver" by Lois Lowry, and also of the "Uglies" Series by Scott Westerfeld. Unfortunately, each of those books is WORLDS better than this one. *Sniff* It had such potential.
There is a sequel to this book called "Bar Code Rebellion". So it could get better. Perhaps I stopped reading in the middle of the story. Could be. As it stands unless the book shows up at Goodwill or becomes available at the library, I probably won't be reading it.
My rating: 3. (I added a point for serious potential...then deducted it for failing to reach it due in large part to the author's lame convenient explanation of the appearance of special abilities. It irritated me. Oh the power!) This book is a young adult science fiction. The character was 17. I'd probably put the book at a 15 year old level. No real language complaints. There was some alluding to possible sex but you didn't really know if it actually happened or if they just made out REALLY well.
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: A watered down version of Uglies.
Sunday, November 23, 2008
"We cannot change the cards we are dealt, just how we play the hand."
A lot of professors give talks titled "The Last Lecture." Professors are asked to consider their demise and to ruminate on what matters most to them. However, when Randy Pausch, a computer science professor at Carnegie Mellon, was asked to give such a lecture, he didn't have to imagine it as his last, since he had recently been diagnosed with terminal cancer. But the lecture he gave--"Really Achieving Your Childhood Dreams"--wasn't about dying. It was about the importance of overcoming obstacles, of enabling the dreams of others, of seizing every moment (because "time is all you have...and you may find one day that you have less than you think"). It was a summation of everything Randy had come to believe. It was about living. - Excerpt from Amazon.com Review
My Review: It is challenging to comment honestly on a book written by a man who has recently passed away, and whose intent in writing was to give his children a way to know him. However, while reading, I found myself comparing this book to Tuesdays with Morrie. I believe this is the only other book like this I’ve read. In doing so I found it an interesting study between the advice given by a 40 year old father of young children, who is arguably “vigorous” until very near the end of his life and that of an aging professor who, aside from living a long, fulfilling life has slow declined into a nearly helpless state. I might as well come clean that I found Tuesdays with Morrie to be the more compelling of the two books, with nearly each page holding a universal wisdom. That is not to say I wouldn’t recommend The Last Lecture - it does have many interesting and useful concepts – it is just that a lot of the advice needed some refinement. And I guess this is the sad part of the story, the author just wouldn’t experience much more of life and its refining abilities. That said here is one of concepts Pausch presents that really struck me. (I will be summarizing this in lieu of searching the book for the exact quote, my apologies) There are a lot of intelligent and capable people working on any number of projects, industries, teams etc. In essence, there is always someone who can do what you do. In order to make yourself truly useful in a unique way you in addition to your skills you need to bring motivation and happiness to the group as a whole.
3.5 stars - while the book wasn't a "fall out of my chair" revelation I think the purpose and context of the writer-ship is admirable.
If I had to sum up this book in one sentence it would be:
A good book to read bits and pieces of on Sunday afternoons.
Friday, November 21, 2008
Thursday, November 20, 2008
My review: Almost from the moment I began reading Girl with a Pearl Earring, I felt as if I was having a calming "zen" moment. I think that it made me relax because it was, simply, a very quiet book. There was very little dialogue...no blaring soundtrack playing in my head.
Tracy Chevalier gives us the uncluttered story of a young girl named Griet who, after her father suffers a crippling accident at work, is forced to work as a maid to save her family from destitution. In the home of the famous painter, Johannes Vermeer, Griet is responsible for many of the household chores, but also for cleaning her master's art studio. She must clean the studio without moving anything, not even an inch, lest she alter the background for his current paintings. As the story progresses, Griet becomes increasingly infatuated, though even she would deny it, with the painter and his paintings. Whether he returns these feelings is unclear throughout much of the book...and so much the better. The quiet moments between them--a word, a glance, a feather-light touch--are drenched with meaning, and leave you feeling like the air has been sucked from the room.
We've all been obsessed, slighted, distracted, disappointed, and persecuted. As a result, I found myself really identifying with many of the characters in this book. Vermeer, so fully obsessed by his art that when he paints he either ignores, or is completely unaware, of the trouble brewing in his home. Catherina, the wife of Vermeer--never the subject of her husband's paintings--never in charge of her own home. She loves her husband but is plagued by insecurities and an inability to understand his work. Griet, who fulfills her duties as a maid and daughter, but is drawn inexblicably to a world that is not her own. Her father, who after a long hard life, has lost the thing he values most. I think everyone who reads this book will loathe Vermeer's eldest daughter, Cornelia, whose innate cruelty is readily apparent. The characters in this book are colorful and well-developed, if not always likable, and they definitely create emotions and sympathy within the reader. The scenes aren't fake or flowery and the result is a smoothly flowing storyline that you can allow yourself to sink into. Through it all Griet struggles to stay true to herself and her upbringing but feels constantly pulled to Vermeer and his paintings. Inevitably, Griet's world comes crashing down when Catherina discovers, what is to her, their ultimate betrayal. Long story short. I loved it. LOVE loved it.
My rating: 5 stars (I own two copies. One to lend. One no one but me touches) No sex but some definitely moments of sensuality. Adult fiction.
Sum it up: Quiet but intense...not something to miss.
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Summary from book, Cover Photo from barnesandnoble.com
My Review: This is one of those books that I finished questioning rather or not I liked it. There are many horrific events in this novel that I didn't enjoy reading, yet it is written in such a way that you are compelled to read more. And in continuing the story you are rewarded with some lovely acts of humanity.
The overall theme of this book was finding one's self. There are two children and a teen that, through events mostly out of their control, are forced to grow up quickly, and in doing so find their true identities. The majority of adults in this story are put into scenarios where they must redefined who they truly are. The main characters in this book are rather likable. I especially loved the quirky old farm brothers. The villains, however, have no redeemable traits.
The author's simple writing style is quite inviting and he is able to almost seamlessly merge several different story lines. However his lack of quotation marks around the dialog drove me crazy and I didn't understand the meaning behind it. I also feel the story ended rather abruptly, leaving me unsatisfied. There is a followup book, "Eventide", that I will probably be checking out, though I can't say I am in a terrible rush to do so.
My Rating: 3.5 Stars, a better than average book but not at the top of my list. (Definitely rated for a mature audience)
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: A simple, mostly pleasant, ride on a dusty, bumpy dirt road.
Saturday, November 15, 2008
Summary: "LITTLE PRINCESS, LOVELY AS THE DAWN, WELL-NAMED AURORE..." With these seemingly innocent words, the fate of a newborn princess is sealed. For years the king and queen despaired of ever having a child. When Aurore arrives, though the entire kingdom celebrates, not all are overjoyed. They use her christening as an occasion for revenge, and her young life is overshadowed by a curse of death almost as soon as it has begun. Those who can, intervene, but evil has a way of holding fast. A sleep of a hundred years following the pricking of a finger is the best that can be done.
And so Aurore grows up. Forbidden princesslike tasks of embroidery and sewing, she explores the great outdoors, reveling in the flora and fauna that surround her castle home. Then one day she meets a handsome stranger in an enchanted wood and begins an adventure the likes of which she never dreamed of.
This is the story of the Sleeping Beauty, here quite awake and given new voice. Taunted by fate, Aurore soon learns that although she cannot sidestep her own destiny, love itself is actually the most powerful magic of all.
My review: As with the last book of hers that I reviewed (The Story Teller's Daughter), Dokey begins with her preamble, or as she calls it "a fancy way of saying Introduction." Her preamble is a gateway to the story...a sort of preparation, if you will, that allows you to shake off your current setting and step over the threshold of Once Upon a Time. I both love and hate it for the anticipation that it builds. Before reading this book, I pretty much considered myself an expert on all things Sleeping Beauty...having watched it a kabillion times with my five-year old. "Beauty Sleep" turned the traditional story all on its head while still maintaining its basic integrity. Aurore is a loveable, curious tomboy being held within the confines of her father's castle in an effort to protect herself from harm--and from a curse given to her by an ordinary, if all to often over looked, young woman. Through the intervention of her cousin Oswald, she is able to venture further out of doors and into the kingdom she has come to love. As her sixteenth year comes to its close, the land is beset by a number of catastrophe's and soon all the signs point to Aurore as the cause. The young princess sets off on her own to find a way to save those she loves from further heartache and along her way she encounters a strange young man, magical moving cabins, stubborn trees, apple fields that last forever and a number of other obstacles. Through it all, Aurore comes to understand where her heart truly lies. "Beauty Sleep" is the exact opposite of what we have come to expect from the typical damsel-in-distress fairytale. Above all, I was enchanted with the heroine that Cameron Dokey created. Aurore is full of fire, determination, sarcasm and wit. She doesn't simper, wave, or swoon as we are so often taught to expect from your everyday Princess, but stands tall in the face of opposition. It is for that reason I think I find this story most appealing. I loved "Beauty Sleep" from Preamble to Epilogue and recommend it highly for an afternoon of light, whimsical reading.
My rating: 4 stars. (I'm calling my mom). Rated G
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: A fabulous, magical read for girls young and old....or anyone who loves an old classic seen in a new light.
Friday, November 14, 2008
Summary: In the ruins of a place once known as North America lies the nation of Panem, a shining Capitol surrounded by twelve outlaying districts. The Capitol is harsh and cruel and keeps the districts in line by forcing them all to send one boy and one girl between the ages of twelve and eighteen to participate in the annual Hunger Games, a fight to the death on live TV.
Sixteen-year-old Katniss Everdeen, who lives alone with her mother and younger sister, regards it as a death sentence when she steps forward to take her sister's place in the games. But Katniss has been close to dead before - and survival, for her, is second nature. Without really meaning to, she becomes a contender. But if she is to win, she will have to start making choices that weigh survival against humanity and life against love. (Summary from book - Image from scificool.com)
My Review: Hunger Games is a fast-paced novel based on a futuristic plot where 24 Tributes from 12 districts must fight against each other to the death. Their war is aired live in a reality TV manner and is required viewing for all citizens. There is never a dull moment during these games. If the tributes aren't fighting against each other then the gamemakers are spicing up the game with ricks of their own.
Suzanne Collins takes you through an entire range of emotions in this action-packed journey. You feel joy over the tributes success. You feel sadness when the tributes are wounded. You feel anger at the gamemakes for the brutal game they invented. The characters in this book are so well-developed that you can't help but to care for them. This leaves the reader feeling tormented because you know only one can survive.
This book is written in a manner that doesn't allow you to put it down. Each chapter ends with an excitement that is carried over to the beginning of the next chapter. You will finish this book wanting more. Luckily this is just the first of a series. I can't wait to see where the next book will take us.
Rating: 5 Stars, I will be recommending this book to everyone, as well as reading it again myself! Rated PG-13 for the violent nature of the plot
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: Hurry up and release the next one please!
My Review: June Parker is a girl trying to find herself. She is in her thirties, single, works as a writer for LA Rideshare and has a limited social life. This is pretty much the extint that we get to know June through the entire book. Actually almost all the characters in this book are under-developed, leaving the reader longing for something more. The exception being Marissa, who is dead before the book even begins.
Completing a life list, especially one written by someone else, makes for an interesting plot. And the list in this book is rather interesting. I found myself wishing the list was a little longer or more challenging but all in all it did contain a fairly good mix. The list contains the potential for a hilarious book mixed with some emotional serious moments.
Unfortunately that is not what comes about. You do get a small chuckle or two but no uncontrollable laughter from reading this novel. And the serious moments lack emotion. The methods in which June goes about completing this list are fairly dull and unrealistic. Everything seemed to fall together without enough action to engage the reader.
There are some unpredictable moments in the second half of the book that keep it from flopping altogether, but nothing so spectacular that will have me recommending or even remembering this book. Overall I feel this book did a decent job of setting up the reader but then continued to just let the reader fall.
Rating: 2.5 Stars, Just so-so, not sorry that I read it but probably won't think about it again.
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: An easy, mindless read that would wedge well between more thought-provoking books (or under the short leg of a table).
Sunday, November 9, 2008
Summary: Rowena, the youngest of twelve sisters, loves to slip from her castle at night and dance in a magical forest. Soon she convinces her sister to join her. When Sir Ethan notices that his daughters slippers look tattered every morning, he is certain they've been sneaking out. So he posts a challenge to all the suitors in the kingdom: The first man to discover where his daughters have been is free to marry the one he chooses. Meanwhile a handsome young knight named Bedivere is involved in a challenge of his own: to return the powerful sword Excalibur, to a mysterious lake. While looking for the lake, Bedivere meets the beautiful Rowena and falls for her. Bedivere knows that accepting Sir Ethan's challege is the only opportunity for him to be with Rowena forever. But this puts both Bedivere and Rowena in a dangerous situation...one in which they risk their lives for a chance at love.
My review: First, let me say one thing....Bedivere? What the heck? What poor intoxicated mother names her child "Bedivere". It is nearly as bad as "Renesmee" (I said nearly). There, now that I've gotten that out of the way I can proceed.
In The Night Dance, Rowena and her sisters are being held captive within the walls of their own home by a well-meaning, but lovelorn and highly paranoid, father. Gifted with a second-sight inherited from her absent mother, Rowena's visions allow her glimpses of the world beyond the manor's high walls. One day, after sneaking through the outer wall, she finds herself in a shared vision with a very handsome young knight in peril. Rowena feels instantly drawn to him and he to her. The Night Dance is the wonderfully light, yet magical, story of their search for each other and their struggles to finish their own personal quests.
Aside from the fact that the title of this book lends itself more to the average romance novel and makes you less likely to, say, take it on a plane, I really enjoyed myself....for the two hours it took to read. The only thing that kept me from reading it in one straight sitting was my two beautiful children who, on occassion, like me to interact with them. TND is a charming mixture of Arthurian legend and the classic Grimm's fairytale of the twelve dancing princesses (I confess that my familiarity with the latter is based almost entirely on the Barbie DVD by the same name). For the most part, I was impressed by Weyn's ability to blend the two famous legends together so seamlessly and intrigued to see how it would work out. Unfortunately, while the ending was fairly good, it seemed to be a little rushed. I definitely would have stuck around for a longer story or, at the very least, a more detailed epilogue.
My rating: 3.5 stars. (I'd like to buy it so that I can read it to my kids when they are a bit older. ) RATED PG
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: A lovely vacation that was over way too soon.
Summary: Once upon a time there lived a king whose heart was heavy. He had been betrayed by the woman he loved. Though the queen's schemes were discovered before she could deprive her husband of his life, her dying curse killed something deep within him: his ability to love and trust. And so he makes a terrible resolution: He will take a bride for one night only. In the morning she will face a horrible fate. Then he will choose another. Nothing can change his course, until one brave woman steps forward. Sharhrazad, the Storyteller's Daughter.
Steeped in the ancient art of her mother's people, Shahrazad embarks upon a perilous course. With words alone, she will seek to retore the king's heart. As she tells her talkes a bond forms between them that neither can deny. But will it be strong enough to hold them together when unexpected danger erupts.
My review: This story is by far my favorite of the three that I have read so far. The beginning is narrated in the first person and has the effect of drawing you in. It makes you feel like you are huddled around a gypsy campfire listening to an old woman relate a story that has been handed down for generations. All of the characters, even the "villains" were well written and tangible. Shahrazad's stories to the king were fascinating in their own right but had definite parallels to her own tale woven into them. The fantasy and magic element was light and enhanced the storyline, rather than detracting from it. I have never read the original tale of Shahrazad and so it is difficult for me to compare the two. In it's own right, "The Storyteller's Daughter" was a fun story that kept and held my attention from beginning to end.
My rating: 4 stars (a near tie with The Night Dance) RATED PG
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: Good stories within a good story.
Summary: In My of 1756 war is breaking out between the British and the French. During this highly dangerous time, Isabella Stevens is traveling with her father to the Britsih stronghold of Fort William Henry. In the forest, Wusamequin, the young and handsome medicine man, looks to avenge the death of his wife and child at the hands of British soldiers. When Wusamequin spots Isabella and her father, he alerts his warriors to capture them. But Wusamequin is quite taken with how bravely Isabella battles. He orders the warriors to spare her and her father, and they are dragged back to their village. However, many members of the Mohican tribe still want them to be killed. In a desperate plea to Wusamequin, Isabella vows to stay as his hostage if he lets her father go.
My review: As previously stated, I'm a sucker for the retold fairytale. In my mind they are the literary equivalent to a fudgsicle--sweet, fun to eat, zero nutrional value, and easily polished off in one sitting. I enjoyed reading this retelling of Beauty and the Beast. NH definitely wrote it into a setting that I had never read before, which always succeeds in capturing my interest. She admits to being inspired a great deal by "Last of the Mohicans" which is one of my favorite movies (no I have NOT read the book). The story itself was unique and dealt a great deal in Isabella and Wusamequins views and prejudices about eachother and then, in turn, the British perception of Native Americans and vice versa. Both sides were portrayed as equally bloodthirsty and vengeful--but with a sense that it was all some huge misunderstanding that could be cleared up if they would just stop fighting long enough to speak to one another. Clearly, according to history, that didn't happen. That having been said, I don't know enough about Native American culture or its individual tribe culture to make a statement as to the veracity of the characters in this book. Where they wearing the right clothes? cooking the right food? speaking the right language? I have no idea, but I have a feeling that the ACLU could have a field day with this book in terms of its portrayal of the Native American. I, quite frankly, dispute a few of the assertions made in the above summary (found on the back of the book). As far as I can see (teensy spoiler here), Isabella never vowed to stay as a hostage but was instead the only one that was caught in an escape attempt. Throughout the book I kept having to hop from one genre (historical fiction) to another (fantasy) to quickly for my taste and I found the end to be a little bit too "folkloric" for me. I guess I wanted a good old happy-on-this-earth ending. Still, as retellings go, it was definitely a unique and enjoyable one time read.
My rating: 3 stars (Fun read. One time. Will recommend to my Mom, a fellow "Last of the Mohicans" fan) RATED PG
If I could sum this book up in one phrase it would be: It was a good fudgsicle...but I'm not sure the fudgsicle would be universally appreciated.
Thursday, November 6, 2008
Josie Cormier was Peter's one true friend. She was the only one that would stand up for him. But all that changed as the two entered middle school and Josie realized that she was being defined by her peers according to her friendship with Peter. In an attempt to fit in with the popular kids, Josie dumped Peter, choosing popularity over friendship.
One day Peter snaps. He opens fire at the school, killing ten students and wounding many more. The trial that results from Peter's actions is the basis for this novel, filled with thought-provoking background information and a couple twists.
My Review: Jodi Picoult takes you for an emotional journey in "Nineteen Minutes". How can you care about a character that is a cold-blooded killer? Yet you do come to care about Peter and even somewhat identify with him.
Here's the story of a boy who was bullyed all his life and this is the result of that behavior. The books asks the reader at one point to recall a memory from junior high or high school. It states that for the majority of us it will be a painful memory that first creeps into our head, an embrassing moment, a moment when our peers had a good laugh at our expense. Most of us are able to get past the incident, realizing that although it may be truely humilating at the time, it is not such a big deal in the grand scheme of things. But what if everyday was filled with painfully embrassing incidents? What if these incidents defined you as a person? How would that have changed who you are today?
The story also suggests that even the popular kids have insecurity problems. That they, too are unable to define themselves beyond the definations set by their peers. They stumble along trying to balance between the person they are and the person they are expected to be by others. Sometimes the result of this imperfect balance is bullying another student to be more liked by your own group. Having grown up somewhere in the middle of the pack, this is a novel idea to me, but one I certainly phanthom being true.
What type of mother raises a killer? This is the question Picoult addresses in her book. As it turns out, it may not be a mother too different from your own or even you. It's just a mother doing what everyone of us does, what she feels is best for her child, though her desicions may differ from your own. Picoult writes "Children don't make their own mistakes. They plunge into a pit they have been led to by their parents." This really made me think about the pits I may be leding my children to. I'm not sure that there is a way to avoid all pits. Maybe the key is to teach your child to step around. Or maybe it's just being there so that when they do take that tragic step they are not free-falling.
This novel really gave me a slightly new view on parenthood. I believe that I will focus a little more on tolerence, preach individuality, seek signs of bullying and remember how everything seems so important when we are young and can't see the grand picture.
My Rating: 4 1/2 Stars (deducting a half for the twists being somewhat predictable) This is a novel that I will be recommending to others, a novel whose characters stay with you.
If I could Sum this book up in one phrase it would be: An emotional, thought-provoking rollercoaster that must be riden.